Math Scores Are Stuck While Reading Improves: Ask Why

Reading scores got the policy spotlight. Math didn't. Here's what the 2025 PISA data reveals, and 7 questions every parent should ask their district now.

Eagle Report
Data-driven accountability piece

by High School of America

The District Fixed Reading. So Why Is Math Still Broken?

Reading instruction had its moment. States mandated curriculum overhauls. Principals got training. Parents got results. And somewhere in the middle of all that progress, math quietly got left behind.

The 2025 PISA results, published by the OECD, confirmed what attentive parents already suspected: student performance in reading and mathematics declined sharply across OECD countries, but the trajectories are not symmetric. Reading has policy momentum behind it. Math does not. And the gap between those two subjects is now a documented, international story.

The Center for American Progress responded to the 2025 PISA data by publishing a framework of five evidence-based strategies to improve U.S. K-12 math achievement. The fact that such a piece needed to be written tells you where math instruction currently sits: behind, and scrambling to catch up.


Reading Got a Revolution. Math Got a Shrug.

The Science of Reading movement gave districts a clear mandate: scrap programs that weren't working, adopt structured literacy, measure phonics outcomes, train teachers differently. It was uncomfortable. It was also effective enough that reading became a political success story.

Math instruction never got that forcing function. There was no equivalent public pressure campaign, no curriculum mandate with teeth, no widespread parent movement demanding that districts account for what "math class" actually means.

The result is predictable. Districts that invested seriously in literacy infrastructure celebrated gains. The same districts, when asked about math outcomes, often point to the same flat trend lines they had three years ago. Progress in one subject does not transfer automatically to another, especially when the policy attention, budget allocation, and teacher preparation pipelines are pointed in completely different directions.

On the teacher pipeline specifically: a 2024 Learning Policy Institute report on teacher certification in Texas found that districts face compounding challenges recruiting and retaining credentialed math educators. Math certification requires demonstrated subject-matter competency that generalist credentials do not. When a district fills a math vacancy with an out-of-field teacher, the credential gap often stays invisible to parents until test scores surface it, and sometimes not even then.


The Eagle Report eagle

Eagle’s pro tip
Policy changes before anyone announces it

The rule that affects your kid is usually settled in a board meeting months before a letter goes home. I read those. Get it while it still matters.




What Actually Moved the Needle: Two District Profiles

Two patterns show up consistently in districts that have moved math scores, as opposed to districts that only claimed to.

High-dosage tutoring with subject-specific math focus. Several urban districts, including some in the Chicago metro area that serve communities similar to those near Naperville and Hoffman Estates, have piloted structured small-group math tutoring during the school day rather than as an after-school add-on. The key variable is not tutoring itself. It is frequency, dosage, and whether the tutor is trained in the specific math curriculum the student is using. Tutoring programs that run three or more sessions per week and align directly to classroom content show measurable gains. Programs that run once a week on whatever the student happens to bring that day show almost nothing.

Instructional coaching tied to a single adopted curriculum. Districts that see math improvement typically made a harder call upstream: they adopted one coherent math curriculum, trained teachers on that curriculum specifically, and then deployed instructional coaches whose only job was to help teachers implement it with fidelity. That is a significant operational investment. Districts that instead gave teachers freedom to mix materials, pull from multiple platforms, and "supplement as needed" saw no consistent gains. The flexibility felt professional. The outcomes told a different story.

These are not comfortable findings for districts to advertise. A parent asking about math curriculum coherence may get a long answer about differentiation and student-centered learning. The question worth pressing is simpler: does every fifth-grade math teacher in this building use the same core program in the same sequence? If the answer is no, the district has identified its own problem.


The Accountability Layer Is You

The Learning Policy Institute has a live webinar scheduled for September 24, 2026, titled "Improving Student Achievement: What Red, Blue, and Purple States Are Doing Right." The fact that researchers are still convening around basic questions of what works, and treating it as news, should recalibrate expectations. Systemic math improvement is not widespread. Districts doing it well are the exception, and they tend to be able to describe exactly what they changed and why.

Parents are the only accountability layer that operates at the classroom level. State data is delayed. Federal data is aggregated. District communications are curated. A parent who asks the right questions in the right room can surface information that never appears in a press release.

If your district is also navigating other pressures on math instruction, the AP and Honors Pressure in Public Schools breakdown at HSOA is worth reading alongside this one. The acceleration pipeline and the foundational math crisis are connected in ways most districts have not acknowledged publicly.


7 Questions to Ask Your District About Math Instruction

These are not gotcha questions. They are the questions any serious district should be able to answer without hesitation. If the answers are vague, incomplete, or redirect to test scores without explaining what caused them, that is information.

  • What is the district's adopted core math curriculum, and is it the same curriculum used by every teacher at each grade level? "We use a variety of resources" is not an answer to this question.

  • How many math teachers in this school are teaching outside their certified subject area, and what support do they receive? Out-of-field teaching in math is common and rarely disclosed proactively.

  • What math-specific professional development did teachers complete in the last 12 months, and how many hours did it involve? General instructional coaching is not the same as math-specific curriculum training.

  • How does the district measure math progress between state assessments, and how often do parents see those results? If the only data point a family gets is annual state scores, the district is operating with a lag that makes intervention nearly impossible.

  • What intervention exists for students who are more than one grade level behind in math, and how is eligibility determined? "We offer tutoring" is not a program. Ask for the structure, the frequency, and the evidence that it worked.

  • How have math scores at this school changed over the last three years, by grade level? Schools that can answer this question specifically, with actual numbers, have been paying attention. Schools that respond with districtwide averages or general trend language have not.

  • What is the district doing differently in math instruction in 2026 compared to 2024? If the answer is nothing, or nothing specific, then the flat trend line will continue to be flat.


Families who are already operating outside the traditional district system, whether through online programs or hybrid models, face a version of this same question. Knowing what math rigor actually looks like, and being able to evaluate it, matters regardless of where your student learns. For families exploring those options, the Columbus K-12 Online Home School page and Clearwater Online High School are two places to start comparing what structured math instruction looks like in a different environment.

The reading gains are real. Nobody is disputing that. The question is whether districts earned the credibility to coast, or whether parents are about to discover that one subject got fixed while the other one quietly fell further behind.

Ask the questions. Get specific answers. The districts that are serious about math will not be confused by any of the above.

From Eagle
Explore High School of America
Self-paced, accredited K-12. Talk to a counselor to see if it’s the right fit for your family.

Get the Eagle Report
In Your Inbox
Education news that actually matters, 3x per week, no noise.